Patent Law Practice Center

Issuance Of Continuation Patents During Litigation Undermine Defense To Willful Infringement

The following post comes from Scott A. McKeown, partner at Oblon Spivak, Practice Center Contributor and writer for Patents Post Grant.

Texas Court Likens Issuance of Continuation Patents During Litigation to Patent Reexamination

[W]illful infringement exists where an accused infringer acted “despite an objectively high likelihood that its actions constituted infringement of a valid patent.” In re Seagate Technology, LLC, 497 F.3d 1360, 1371 (Fed. Cir. 2007). In assessing the propriety of a post-filing willfulness allegation (i.e., after the  complaint is filed with the court) Seagate is oft cited for the proposition that a plaintiff must seek injunctive relief (i.e., preliminary injunction). However, court’s have refused to impose such a wooden rule. Instead, court’s look to the totality of the circumstances, including factors such as the existence of concluded patent reexaminations. (more…)

The ITC End-Around District Court Stays Pending Patent Reexamination

The following post comes from Scott A. McKeown, partner at Oblon Spivak, Practice Center Contributor and writer for Patents Post Grant.

The greatest season of the year, is neither winter, spring, summer or fall, it is football season. Despite the fact that my Eagles are looking hapless these days, and my fantasy football teams are already in the toilet (thanks a lot Larry Fitzgerald), still the NFL season is always exciting. Teams once left for dead rise again, Hail Mary’s are answered (unless Jason Avant is involved, curse his name) and last second strategies rule the day.

What does all of this have to do with patent law?….nothing really, patent law is nowhere near as exciting. Yet, every once in awhile a new strategy appears that changes the game. Much like the NFL, patent practice is a “copycat league,” so, very likely coming to a patent litigation near you….the “ITC end-around.”

For those not familiar with the football end-around, this play, as diagrammed above is an exercise in misdirection. With a very aggressive defense going one way, an offensive team fakes into the direction of the defense, only to toss the ball to a player running around the defense in the opposite direction. A form of this tactic was recently executed by Motiva in their dispute with Nintendo. (more…)