Patent Law Practice Center

Reexamination Strategies Concurrent with Litigation

The following post comes from Scott A. McKeown, partner at Oblon Spivak, Practice Center Contributor and writer for Patents Post Grant

I.  The Multi-Purpose Litigation Tool

The initiation of patent reexamination for patents subject to concurrent litigation can provide strategic benefits independent of the ultimate outcome of the reexamination. These litigation inspired applications of patent reexamination can be thought of as falling into one of two categories, namely, pre-trial maneuvers or post-trial, damage control.

Pre-trial Maneuvers are those patent reexaminations initiated to potentially enhance a defendant’s battle in the district court.  For example, patent reexamination may be sought as vehicle to stay a district court litigation. Still other defendants initiate patent reexamination concurrent with litigation as a mechanism to leverage more acceptable settlement terms, provide additional prosecution history for claim construction, avoid injunctive relief, demonstrate the materiality of a reference subject to an inequitable conduct defense, or establish objectively reasonable behavior for use in preventing a post-complaint willfulness finding. (more…)