Patent Litigation Strategies for Retailers Based Upon the PWC Patent Litigation Study


R. David Donoghue, Partner at Holland & Knight and Practice Center Contributor, passed along this post he wrote for his Retail Patent Litigation blog that discusses PWC’s 2011 Patent Litigation Study.

I [recently] wrote about some key implications of PWC’s excellent 2011 patent litigation study.  The study is so dense that it deserves more discussion.  Here are several of the key takeaways from the study.

  • Big Dollars for Trolls.  Troll damages awards were nearly double those of practicing entities received by practicing entities.
  • NPE’s Are Not All Equal.  Looking at all non-practicing entities, universities and non-profits are more successful than trolls, but their median damages awards are considerably lower.
  • Trolls Wither on the Papers.  Trolls and practicing plaintiffs are equally successful at trial, but practicing entities are much more successful winning on summary judgment. 

There are several important points and strategies to draw from these statistics:

  1. Keep Trolls Off Their Feet.  Trolls may not win more often in the courtroom, but when they do they get juries to give them more money.  Even though judges later fix some of the awards, that is still a bad trend.  And trolls do not do as well on the papers where accuracy, organization, research, and clear writing carry the day.  So, retailers should be driving toward clear summary judgment motions and bench trials when possible.
  2. Fight Fire With Fire.  When choosing counsel look for counsel who are not just technically and legally sound, but can also advocate and persuade.  It is obviously critical to be able to counter the troll’s courtroom effectiveness.
  3. Focus on Trial.  Using skilled advocates is important, but the most skilled advocate is only as valuable as the facts they have to work with.  So, you need to set up defense strategies with a focus on trial — even if you never expect to go to trial.  Your entire defense should be colored by preparing for trial and your trial strategy, not just meeting case deadlines.

Tags: , , ,

Leave a Reply

You share in the PLI Practice Center community, so we just ask that you keep things civil. Leave out the personal attacks. Do not use profanity, ethnic or racial slurs, or take shots at anyone's sexual orientation or religion. If you can't be nice, we reserve the right to remove your material and ban users who violate our Terms of Service.

You must be logged in to post a comment.